Can common healthcare, entry to consuming water be handled as ‘freebies’, asks Supreme Court


The Supreme Court on Wednesday asserted that it can’t stop political events from making guarantees and that it was important to outline what’s a “freebie”.

“Can universal healthcare, access to drinking water, and access to consumer electronics be treated as freebies?” requested a bench headed by Chief Justice of India N V Ramana, the Bar and Bench reported. The apex court docket was listening to a petition by BJP chief and advocate Ashwini Upadhyay looking for to forestall political events from promising freebies to the citizens earlier than elections.

The CJI famous that one of many ideas from the respondents said that political events can’t be prevented from making guarantees to the citizens. “I don’t think promises alone are the basis of parties being elected. Some make promises and even then they are not elected,” the CJI stated.

The court docket requested all events involved to submit their opinions and listed the matter for additional listening to subsequent Monday (August 22). The CJI added that it have to be ensured that every one events to the case are equipped with copies of the purposes.

Subscriber Only Stories

Earlier, the CJI had acknowledged that the impression of freebies promised by political events on the nation’s fiscal well being was “a serious issue” however stated he was not in favour of derecognising any social gathering over it as a result of that may be “anti-democratic”.

The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) has sought to oppose the ban on freebies. It instructed the court docket “schemes for socioeconomic welfare of deserving and disadvantaged masses cannot be described as ‘freebies’”.

On Wednesday, the CJI noticed, “We cannot prevent political parties from making promises. The question is what qualifies as a freebie. Can we describe the promise of free education, some essential units of power as freebies? There has to be debate and discussion.”

— with inputs from Bar and Bench


Recent Articles

Related Stories