Residents in Goochland County, Virginia, were surprised when an official packet restoring civil rights arrived addressed to “Biscuit Rigsby,” a dog who has died. The apparent mistake has drawn the attention of state lawmakers and renewed scrutiny of the process used to restore voting and other civil rights to people convicted of felonies.
- An official document restoring civil rights was addressed to a deceased dog in Goochland County, Virginia, prompting calls for an investigation.
- Governor Spanberger’s office says the record corresponds to a person with a Social Security number and denies restoring rights to an animal.
- The incident spotlights database and oversight risks in a process where the governor signs individualized restorations and occurs amid a push to make restorations automatic by constitutional amendment.
What happened
In early September, a packet from the Secretary of the Commonwealth informing recipients that Governor Abigail D. Spanberger had restored certain civil rights was delivered to an address in Gum Spring. The formal document, signed by the governor, listed the name “Biscuit Rigsby” three times, according to reporting by Cardinal News and Virginia Scope. Local residents told reporters Biscuit was a pet who had died, and one owner — who asked to remain anonymous — confirmed the dog’s death and said Biscuit never showed interest in voting.
Official response and disputed explanations
A spokesperson for Governor Spanberger’s administration told journalists that the office did not restore a dog’s rights and that the record in question is associated with a person who has a date of birth and a Social Security number. The spokesperson did not provide further identifying details, citing privacy limits.
Republican Delegate Tom Garrett of Buckingham County publicly called for an investigation into the governor’s review process, saying Virginians deserve assurance the governor knows whether people whose rights are being restored are alive and are in fact persons. Garrett’s statement, reported by Virginia Scope and Cardinal News, framed the matter as non-partisan oversight of how restorations are handled.
How this connects to broader problems
Reporters and some officials have said this incident is one of several recent cases in which restoration-of-rights notices went to improbable recipients — including people listed with no last name or deceased people. Governor Spanberger has told a Richmond TV station that she suspects errors originate in government databases and that her administration is looking into the problem, according to Cardinal News.
Virginia is among a small number of states where restoration of civil rights after a felony conviction currently requires an explicit act by the governor rather than happening automatically after release or a waiting period. Cardinal News compiled historical totals showing that the number of restorations varies dramatically by governor; it listed approximately 66,085 restorations under Governor Spanberger to date. That history and Virginia’s constitutional requirement that the governor report the “particulars of every case” to the General Assembly are central to debates about both process and accountability.
Why the governor’s signature matters
Legal experts and reporting sources note that Virginia’s Supreme Court has interpreted the constitution to require individualized consideration for each restoration, including communication to the legislature explaining particulars and reasons. Cardinal News reviewed the 2016 Howell v. McAuliffe litigation and subsequent rulings that rejected a blanket restoration as inconsistent with that individualized-review requirement. Those earlier cases underscore why critics say a signed document bearing the governor’s name — even if it arose from a database glitch — raises questions about whether the process was performed case by case.
Timing and political context
The Biscuit incident occurred during an election season in which Virginians were voting on a proposed constitutional amendment (Amendment 3) that would change the mechanism for restoring rights, making restoration automatic upon completion of a sentence. Supporters of the amendment argue that an automatic process eliminates the risk of political discretion or error; opponents counter that some cases may warrant individual consideration. Reporting on Biscuit and similar anomalies has fed public debate over those competing approaches.
Unresolved questions
- How did the name “Biscuit Rigsby” become linked to the record used to generate a governor-signed restoration document? Cardinal News suggested possibilities including data co-mingling, mis-entered names, or a convicted person having used the name at some point, but no definitive public explanation has been provided.
- Does the Secretary of the Commonwealth maintain an audit trail that can show the source record and any manual steps taken before the governor signed the restoration? Governor Spanberger’s office has declined to release identifying details, citing privacy.
- Are there systemic errors in the databases used to identify restoration candidates — for example, mixing pet-license data, court records and corrections records — and, if so, what safeguards can prevent recurrence?
Practical implications and next steps
Officials in the governor’s office said they are investigating the source of these erroneous mailings, according to Cardinal News. Delegate Garrett has called for an investigation; reporters note similar letters have appeared in other locations, including a person listed only as “Betty No Last Name.”
For voters and for people tracking rights restoration policy, the episode has several immediate implications: it highlights the importance of accurate recordkeeping where civil rights depend on administrative action; it may strengthen arguments for an automatic-restoration amendment promoted by its backers; and it raises potential legal and ethical questions about the governor’s role when signed documents are produced from imperfect data. At least one commentator has argued — based on the Howell precedent — that the constitutional duty to review “on an individualized, case-by-case basis” makes the governor’s signature the focal point of any inquiry.
Timeline
- September 4, 2026 — The certificate in question is dated this day, according to Virginia Scope reporting.
- Late October–early November 2026 — Local media outlets in Virginia report that a restoration packet was delivered to the Gum Spring address for “Biscuit Rigsby,” prompting attention from Del. Tom Garrett and coverage by Cardinal News and Virginia Scope.
- Early November 2026 — Governor’s office confirms it did not intentionally restore a dog’s rights and says the record corresponds to a person with a date of birth and Social Security number; calls for investigation are publicized.
What to watch
Key developments to monitor include whether the governor’s office releases an audit trail or more detailed explanation of how the record was selected, whether the General Assembly or an independent body opens a formal review, and whether the outcome of the proposed constitutional amendment alters the process for restoring rights in a way that reduces reliance on manual, governor-signed restorations.
What sources say
This story relies on reporting from Cardinal News and Virginia Scope, which documented the delivery of a governor-signed restoration packet addressed to “Biscuit Rigsby” and reported on statements from the governor’s spokesperson and calls from Delegate Tom Garrett for an investigation. Cardinal News provided historical totals for restorations under recent governors and context about the constitutional requirements; Virginia Scope published the account that included direct reporting from the dog’s owner and the September 4 certificate date.
“Of course we did not restore the rights of a dog,” — governor’s office spokesperson (as reported by Virginia Scope and Cardinal News).
Orbital Affairs will continue to follow official updates and any formal inquiries into the administration’s restoration process.







